How to Choose a Trustworthy Matchmaker in (2025)

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify

When we founded Ambiance Matchmaking in 2002, only a handful of matchmakers existed. Though matchmaking is one of the world’s most ancient professions, it didn’t become well-known in the United States until the rise of online dating in the 21st century. In pop culture, reality shows such as Millionaire Matchmaker and Indian Matchmaker continued to popularize the industry. For already established companies, this shift was great news. However, this caused a large influx of less experienced matchmakers to flood the space. The Matchmaking Institute estimates that there are now more than 2,000 matchmakers in the industry. This has caused some conflict as there is no required certification process to become a professional matchmaker, and it’s now much more difficult to choose a trustworthy, respectable matchmaker with a positive track record. 

However, great matchmakers exist; it’s just a matter of finding them. The most reliable way to assess a matchmaking agency’s stability is to look at its number of years in business. Remember when I said there were just a handful of matchmakers back in 2002? Well, they are still around today and are current leaders in the industry. They include Kelleher International (established in 1986 by Jill and Amber Kelleher), Selective Search (established in 2000 by Barbie Adler), Ambiance Matchmaking (established in 2002 by Leslie Wardman), and Linx Dating (established in 2003 by Amy Anderson). Keep in mind, these agencies are considered “high-end” and come with a hefty price tag. 

The industry is comprised of a variety of matchmaking agencies, and each represents a different kind of business model, price point, geographic parameter, value and belief system, experience and knowledge, and personality and ethos. Depending on these factors, matchmakers will vary greatly in the quality of services and costs. For example, low-end matchmakers have a high acceptance rate, low costs, and offer less personalized services. High-end matchmakers accept a small number of clients per year to dedicate more time and resources to their clients’ search, therefore it is very personalized and requires a much higher fee. It is important that you do your homework and ask the right questions to determine which firm is right for you, and that is exactly what we’ll discuss in the guide. In the next chapter, we will discuss the different price points of matchmaking agencies.

CONTINUE TO CHAPTER 2

Leslie Wardman

Leslie is the Founder and Matchmaker of Ambiance Matchmaking. Her 30 years in the matchmaking industry has given her one-of-a-kind insight and intuition in the dating and relationship space. In her writing, she combines her own personal experience with dating, marriage, and divorce, with the knowledge gained from working with hundreds of thousands of singles. She is the author of Love, Dating & The Beatles and is currently writing her second book, Marriage & The 17-Year Itch.

More Blog Articles

Make Your Voice Note Feel Like a Love Letter (2025)

Make Your Voice Note Feel Like a Love Letter (2025)

In a world flooded with instant messaging and dating apps, it's easy to feel disconnected—even when you're constantly in touch ...
The Rise of Slow Love in Gen Z Dating Culture (2025)

The Rise of Slow Love in Gen Z Dating Culture (2025)

In a world where dating apps, swipe culture, and fast-paced romances have become the norm, something surprising is happening: Gen ...
Love in the AI Age: Can AI Help Us Date Better? (2025)

Love in the AI Age: Can AI Help Us Date Better? (2025)

In a world increasingly shaped by technology, it's no surprise that love and relationships are evolving too. Gone are the ...
How Emily Met John: A Modern Classic Love Tale

How Emily Met John: A Modern Classic Love Tale

In an era where swipes and DMs dominate the dating scene, the love story of Emily Blunt and John Krasinski ...
Is Your Type Blocking Love? Date Outside the Mold

Is Your Type Blocking Love? Date Outside the Mold

We’ve all heard it — or said it ourselves: “I’m just into athletic types.”“I only date creatives.”“I could never date ...
Digital Nomads in Love: Real Challenges

Digital Nomads in Love: Real Challenges

Remote work has reshaped how we live — and how we love. As more people embrace the digital nomad lifestyle, ...
How Money Mindset Impacts Who You Date

How Money Mindset Impacts Who You Date

How Your Relationship with Money Affects Who You Date (and How You Love) Love and money are more intertwined than ...
The Slow Burn Romance of Rihanna & A$AP

The Slow Burn Romance of Rihanna & A$AP

In the whirlwind world of celebrity dating, it’s easy to assume that romances spark on red carpets or in the ...
Therapy Talk Is Hotter Than Six-Figure Salaries

Therapy Talk Is Hotter Than Six-Figure Salaries

We’re living in a time where the sexiest thing someone can say on a first date isn’t “I make six ...
Single Dads Deserve Love This Father’s Day

Single Dads Deserve Love This Father’s Day

Father’s Day is a special time to honor the strength, sacrifice, and devotion of dads everywhere. But today, we want ...
Serena’s Romantic Journey with Alexis Ohanian

Serena’s Romantic Journey with Alexis Ohanian

From Friendship Circles to Forever: How Serena Williams and Alexis Ohanian Found Love In the world of celebrity romances, chance ...
The One That Got Away: Could You Reconnect?

The One That Got Away: Could You Reconnect?

We’ve all got that one person — the almost. The “what if.” The relationship that didn’t quite blossom, or the ...